New Strategies Deployed in Abortion Battle

The Wall Street Journal The Wall Street Journal

WASHINGTON—As the fight between antiabortion activists and abortion-rights supporters about the use of fetal tissue in medical research enters its third week, both sides have shifted tactics in their battle.

For abortion opponents, secretly recorded videos of abortion providers discussing the procedure have brought some of the most sustained attention to their campaign in years. A new recording released Tuesday showed technicians separating the organs from an aborted fetus.

The videos have unified the often-fragmented antiabortion groups and mark a coming of age for its younger activists, who have pushed to move beyond printed leaflets, graphic posters and attempts to block clinic doors, toward campaigns that can be waged online.

The groups are using the videos to renew a push to cut off government funds to Planned Parenthood, which received about $500 million in those funds last year to provide women’s health services such as contraception. Its clinics also are the nation’s largest and most-organized provider of abortions.

The videos “cut across every one of those divisions” about strategy, said Marjorie Dannenfelser of the Susan B. Anthony List, which supports antiabortion political candidates, and which has been pushing to cut off government funds to Planned Parenthood.

The Rev. Frank Pavone, who heads Priests for Life, a group known for its use of graphic antiabortion images, has been helping to circulate the videos. He said the recordings and the digital dissemination represented a “maturing” of their strategy.

“We began to realize, I could stand on the street all day with a poster and I’ll reach hundreds of people,” he said. “If I stand all day on YouTube, Facebook and Twitter, I could be reaching millions.”

Planned Parenthood officials, meanwhile, have described the videos as an attack on a scale they have never seen before. They are mounting a defensive campaign that is already entering the 2016 presidential race.

Planned Parenthood leaders contend critics are attacking women’s health services more broadly and that the organization will rally support from millions of American women who have used their clinics.

On Tuesday, Planned Parenthood released data from a survey it commissioned from Hart Research Associates. Late last week, 63% of the 800 registered voters polled said they opposed efforts to defund Planned Parenthood; that opposition went as high as 87% among Democrats, said Hart pollster Geoff Garin.

More than half of the women voters surveyed said they had positive feelings about Planned Parenthood, 27% had negative feelings and the rest were ambivalent, Mr. Garin said. Among women respondents, some 23% said they personally had been to a Planned Parenthood clinic, and an additional 16% knew a friend or family member who had.

That kind of support makes attacks on the organization a “substantial political liability,” Mr. Garin said.

Planned Parenthood also has said it is looking into ways to prevent clinics and staff members from being covertly filmed.

“It was unprecedented in its scale,” said Dawn Laguens, executive vice president of Planned Parenthood Action Fund of the creation of the videos. “We have tons of people working on this.”

Antiabortion advocates held rallies nationwide Tuesday, including one on Capitol Hill attended by several Republican supporters.

Late Tuesday, Senate Republicans, including Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R., Ky.), Sen. Joni Ernst (R., Iowa) and Sen. James Lankford (R., Okla.), announced they had drawn up a bill to ban all federal funds to Planned Parenthood clinics. Other women’s health providers would be allowed to get the funds instead, they said.

The measure would be considered by the Senate before the August recess, Mr. McConnell said.

The conservative House Freedom Caucus said Tuesday that its 40 members would resist any funding bill in the lower chamber that doesn’t remove Planned Parenthood dollars.

President Barack Obama addressed Planned Parenthood’s annual conference after the 2012 election and pledged himself “to be right there with you.” He is unlikely to agree to a measure that blocks funds.

Meanwhile, Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky, a candidate for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination, called on the Democratic presidential front-runner Hillary Clinton to reject campaign money and support from Planned Parenthood.

Mrs. Clinton told a cheering crowd Tuesday in Nashua, N.H., that she “will defend a woman’s right to choose” and then raised her voice to add “—and Planned Parenthood!”